ECI Unanimity Records: Petitioner Tells Supreme Court None Produced
A rejoinder says the poll body's claim of collective approval of voter-roll revision orders is unproven; the case was listed before the Supreme Court on 17 November.

Image: LiveLaw
Petitioner Rakesh Kumar Singh has told the Supreme Court that the Election Commission of India has not produced “a single contemporaneous record” showing that its three members approved the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) decisions together. His rejoinder affidavit, filed through Advocate-on-Record Mudit Gupta in his writ petition against the Union of India and listed for hearing on 17 November, answers the Commission’s counter-affidavit and supplementary affidavit, LiveLaw reported on Tuesday.
“An assertion of unanimity is not proof of it,” the affidavit says. The order of the bench on this listing had not been reported when this story was written.
File Notings, Minutes and E-Approvals Sought
Singh wants the court to look at agendas, minutes, file notings, circulation sheets, resolutions, electronic approvals and related communications. These are the papers that would show whether Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar and Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi took each decision jointly, as Section 18 of the 2023 appointments law requires, according to his plea. He also argues that corrective steps taken later cannot retrospectively validate decisions made earlier without that compliance.
Also read Mustafabad Form 7 Complaint: Supreme Court Asks EC to Verify Deletions
For voters, the case matters because the SIR decides who stays on the roll. Several petitions in the batch, including those by Rahul Gandhi and other INDIA bloc leaders, seek to invalidate the exercise. IPB reported on the opposition’s 48 questions to the Commission on 16 November.
What the Commission Told the Court on 26 October
The Commission’s counter-affidavit, filed on 26 October, said all three SIR orders, from June 2025, October 2025 and May 2026, were unanimous decisions of the Commission. It said Form 6 had not been amended, but accepted that the online display could be read as an amendment, so since 21 October the online application has been split into Form 6 and a separate SIR declaration. It also argued that the plea to restrain the CEC is not maintainable under Article 324(5).
On 27 October, senior advocate Abhishek Manu Singhvi asked the court to preserve file notings and internal communications. Chief Justice Surya Kant replied, “We know everything, we will examine,” and gave petitioners 10 days to respond. Earlier, the court declined interim relief and issued notice on the plea seeking the CEC’s suspension. IPB’s earlier report on Form 6 after the SIR draft rolls has the Commission’s position on prosecution. More court reports are collected under the Supreme Court tag.
Decision Rests on What the Bench Orders Today
The next step is the bench’s direction on whether the Commission must place its internal records before the court. If the bench seeks them, the Commission would have to show how each SIR order was approved. No date for a final hearing has been reported.
Source: Based on reporting by LiveLaw, LiveLaw (27 October hearing) and WION.
Image: LiveLaw.




