Pitampura Open Sewer Deaths: Delhi High Court Orders Rs 11 Lakh Each
Two families waited 16 years for an answer on who was responsible for an unguarded sewer in a Delhi park; the court named both agencies.

Image: Delhi High Court / file photo
The Delhi High Court on Thursday, 19 November, held the Delhi Development Authority (DDA) and the Delhi Jal Board (DJB) jointly liable for the deaths of two boys, aged about 11 and 12, who fell into an open sewer in a Pitampura park in April 2010, and ordered Rs 11.01 lakh in compensation to each family, to be borne by the two bodies jointly. Justice Jasmeet Singh allowed two writ petitions the parents filed in 2016, more than six years after the deaths, according to LiveLaw.
Rs 11.01 Lakh Per Family, With 9% Interest
The court fixed compensation of Rs 11.01 lakh for each child, with 9 per cent simple interest a year from the date the petitions were filed, and Rs 1 lakh each in litigation costs, The Tribune reported. The figure was worked out from a monthly income of Rs 6,448 for a child of that age: after a 1.5 multiplier and a 50 per cent deduction for personal expenses, the loss came to Rs 4,836 a month, or Rs 58,032 a year. A multiplier of 15 gave Rs 8,70,480 in pecuniary loss, to which Rs 2,30,147 in standard compensation was added.
The Municipal Corporation of Delhi was let off because it had no role in maintaining the park.
Also read Restaurant Service Charge: Delhi High Court Denies Interim Relief
Why a Four-Foot Wall Was Not Enough
The judge held that an authority responsible for an open sewer in a public park “owes a greater duty of care”, and that boundary walls of four to five feet did not show adequate precautions. The DDA argued the DJB was doing the sewer work; the court said the park fell under the DDA and it could not escape responsibility. It applied the principle of res ipsa loquitur, under which the accident itself points to negligence, and rejected a police report that blamed the children. On how children see such pits, the judgment said they “often perceive inadequately secured pits/areas as curious spaces and not as lethal dangers”, according to LiveLaw.
Sixteen Years After the Deaths
The families waited 16 years from the accident and about 10 years from filing. The reports do not give a deadline for payment, and neither the DDA nor the DJB has said whether it will appeal to a Division Bench. Neither report lists new safety directions for Delhi’s parks. For more on the court’s recent orders affecting the capital, see the Delhi High Court tag.
Source: Based on reporting by LiveLaw and The Tribune. Also reported by ANI.
Image: Justice Jasmeet Singh, Delhi High Court (file photo).




